Senior inflation in IT: why years of experience no longer sell specialists to employers, how companies determine candidates' seniority and who has a better chance of getting an offer

When Oleg was last looking for a job, it was almost a routine procedure: update LinkedIn, write to a few familiar recruiters, respond to a dozen messages in Djinni. In a few weeks, there were final interviews and a choice between two or three offers. At that time, his backend development experience worked almost flawlessly. And for the first time in a long time, the IT professional faced a feeling that he was not prepared for: despite dozens of reviews, some companies did not respond at all, some cut off after the first interview. Several times he reached the final, heard positive feedback, and a few days later received: «We decided to move on with another candidate.»

After the third such rejection, Oleg began to doubt the relevance of his stack, the relevance of his experience. And his story in today’s market is no exception. On specialized forums, on LinkedIn, in private chats, you can increasingly see the same stories: strong candidates with 8–12 years of experience cannot find a new role for months. And this looks especially strange against the background of constant talk about the shortage of qualified technical personnel.

dev.ua asked the largest IT companies what is really happening with the senior market. And the answer turned out to be more complicated than simply «the market has sunk.»

«You are overqualified»: a recruiter’s excuses or a valid reason for rejecting a candidate. What IT professionals and recruiters think about it

On the topic

«You are overqualified»: a recruiter’s excuses or a valid reason for rejecting a candidate. What IT professionals and recruiters think about it

The market has become much more demanding

A few years ago, extensive experience in itself was a strong argument in favor of a candidate. Senior specialists were actively lured away, and the difficulty lay more in choosing between offers than in finding a job. Now the situation is different. The market has not become smaller, but it has become much more demanding about what exactly is behind the line «10+ years of experience» in a resume.

ZONE3000 says: the problem is not a shortage of vacancies. «From our side, the situation looks a little different: we do not experience a shortage of vacancies — on the contrary, we have stable open positions for qualified specialists. But the selection process itself often takes longer,» explains Viktoriya Tomchynska, IT Recruitment Director & Head of Talent Office.

The reason is the increasing complexity of the roles themselves. Companies are no longer looking for just a strong engineer with a lot of experience. They are looking for an exact match with a specific technical stack, product context and business objectives. «Today it is more a question of finding the exact match between the candidate and the objective, rather than a general lack of opportunities in the market,» says Tomczynska.

A similar picture is seen at Sigma Software. «The key role is played by the match between the candidate’s profile and the needs of a specific role,» says Recruitment Team Lead Maria Simantseva. According to her, the reasons for rejections for senior candidates are almost always a combination of factors: technological gaps, irrelevant domain experience, and salary expectations that do not fit into the position’s budget.

Railsware is blunt: extensive experience alone is no longer a guarantee of role fit.

A candidate, she adds, may have strong technical expertise but not fit the company’s product landscape. Or be a very narrow specialist in a technology that is no longer critical to a particular business.

Ciklum states that the requirements for senior-level positions have changed significantly. «Today, candidates, especially at the Senior and Lead levels, are expected not only to have strong technical expertise, but also to have an understanding of the entire product ecosystem, business context, and developed communication skills,» explains Yulia Chervenets, Talent Fulfilment Expert. Now it’s not enough to simply know how to implement a solution; you need to be able to explain why this particular solution is right for the business.

For many experienced professionals, a protracted job search becomes not only a professional but also a psychological challenge. But recruiters agree on one thing: in most cases, the problem is not the loss of value of the candidate. More often, it is about the need to rethink one’s own positioning in the market. This is how Chief People Team at EVO Olena Oleksienko puts it. «The market is becoming more and more experience-driven. Companies are looking not just for a set of skills, but for people who are able to influence business metrics and make decisions with a real economic effect.»

That is why today the key is not the fact of experience itself, but where the candidate’s «cognitive advantage» lies: what exactly he sees better than others, what decisions he can make, and what complexity he is able to withstand.

What «you’re overqualified» really means

The phrase «you are overqualified for this role» sounds like a polite form of rejection without explanation to many. Often candidates take it as a compliment or as the company’s unwillingness to give the real reason.

But for recruiters, this is a very specific risk signal. It’s not that the candidate is «too good,» but rather about doubts about the long-term match between their level, motivation, and the objectives of the role. Many perceive it as a diplomatic form of «you’re not right for us.» But recruiters say: there is often a specific business risk behind this.

Sigma Software explains: overqualified is not «too strong a candidate.» «It’s a mismatch between the candidate’s level and the scope of the role, as well as between their motivation and expectations, which is critical for long-term cooperation,» says Maria Simantseva.

Railsware emphasizes that it is also about the inconsistency of the level of autonomy. A senior specialist who is used to influencing strategic decisions can quickly lose interest in a role where only delivery is expected of him.

However, not all companies use this criterion. ZONE3000 explicitly states: «In our company, the concept of overqualified is not a reason for rejection.»

Another reason experienced IT professionals are rejected is poor positioning. Victoria Pecentii, Career PRO leader at Mate academy, says this is one of the most common problems among experienced professionals. «8 out of 10 candidates, regardless of their level, do not know how to properly write a resume, and LinkedIn profiles are not given any importance at all.» Many senior professionals, Victoria notes, describe processes instead of results: they list the stack, indicate years of experience, but do not explain what business effect they created.

«The higher the level, the higher the expectations. Seniors are not expected to perform tasks, but to take responsibility for the result and influence the business,» Pecentii emphasizes. This is what, according to her, candidates often lack in their self-presentation.

Overqualified developers with 15+ years of experience complain that they can’t find work for a long time. Employers say that such specialists are valued and do not discriminate: what’s going on?

On the topic

Overqualified developers with 15+ years of experience complain that they can’t find work for a long time. Employers say that such specialists are valued and do not discriminate: what’s going on?

Senior today is no longer about years

Recruiters are almost unanimous: years of experience have ceased to be the main marker of seniority.

At PlantIn, level is determined through grading matrices and competencies.

Sigma Software uses internal checklists, while Ciklum uses technical assessment. Railsware, on the other hand, looks at autonomy, ownership, and the ability to influence team outcomes. This explains why the same person can be senior in one company and middle in another — context has become more important than title.

Another factor that recruiters increasingly cite as a barrier to hiring senior executives is their willingness to work with AI. Companies are increasingly evaluating not only a candidate’s classic technical expertise, but also how well they integrate AI tools into their work, whether they can adapt to new approaches, and how quickly they relearn.

Sigma Software, for example, talks about the rapid growth of demand in the Data/AI direction; ZONE3000 expects readiness to quickly retrain taking into account new approaches, Railsware directly talks about the value of AI literacy.

Recruiters are unanimous: this does not mean that a senior has to be an ML engineer, but he must understand how AI is changing his profession and be able to integrate these tools into work processes.

So what should seniors do?

Recruitment experts agree that the market has not become less friendly to experienced engineers — it has become more precise and stricter in its requirements.

Today, it is not enough to simply have solid experience, it is important to be able to show the relevance of your experience, demonstrate adaptability, work with new tools, and explain to the business what value you bring.

Today, ten years on a resume no longer works as an automatic pass to an offer — candidates need to prove the relevance of their expertise, show business thinking, demonstrate adaptability, and be able to explain why your experience solves a specific problem for the company.

Otherwise, even a very strong specialist risks finding himself in Oleg’s situation — when there is a lot of experience, many interviews, but no offer.

«It’s no longer possible to sell a programmer»: Taras Kytsmey on the era of AI agents, domain junkies, and digital «electricity»

On the topic

«It’s no longer possible to sell a programmer»: Taras Kytsmey on the era of AI agents, domain junkies, and digital «electricity»

«How to pass a midwife interview if you’re a jun?» Ukrainian Reddit discusses an offer of 150,000 UAH and whether it’s realistic to «grow up on the go»

On the topic

«How to pass a midwife interview if you’re a jun?» Ukrainian Reddit discusses an offer of 150,000 UAH and whether it’s realistic to «grow up on the go»

If you don’t hire Juns today, you’ll be left without Mids tomorrow. Is the IT market really heading towards a crisis that it is creating itself?

On the topic

If you don’t hire Juns today, you’ll be left without Mids tomorrow. Is the IT market really heading towards a crisis that it is creating itself?

Read the country’s main IT news in our Telegram

On the topic

Read the country’s main IT news in our Telegram